For many borrowers, student loans represent the largest debt on their credit report.
Thus, it shouldn’t come as a surprise that student debt impacts the complicated credit score formula in many different ways.
In this article, I’ll untangle the many different ways student loans may move your credit score up or down. I’ll also share some strategies to help you leverage student loan opportunities into a better credit score.
The Basics: How Student Loans Impact Credit Scores
Before generating a strategy to help your credit score, it is important to first understand the basics.
Three Ways Student Loans Help Your Credit Score
On-Time Payments – Payment history is a huge component of credit scores. If you are making timely monthly payments, you are helping your cause.
Diversified Credit Mix – Lenders want to see that consumers have managed different types of accounts over the years. Student debt adds to the diversity of your credit profile.
Length of Credit History – A limited or non-existent credit history is a significant issue. The longer you have been in the system, the better your score. For many borrowers, their first student loan is the oldest item on their credit report.
Three Ways Student Loans Hurt Your Credit Score
Late Payments – Missing a payment is obviously bad for your credit score. A single late payment can mean a drop of 180 points. Keeping up with student loan bills is often a challenge. As a result, large student loan bills are a massive threat to credit scores.
New Loans Hurt – New student loans can hurt your credit score in two ways. First, the inquiry required to get the new student loan may cause a temporary drop in your score. Second, the new loan lowers the average age of your credit history.
Default – If missing a payment is bad, defaulting is devastating. A default can last on your credit report for up to seven years, and lenders will be reluctant to loan you money in the future.
The Big Credit Impact that Doesn’t Change Your Credit Score
If you are worried about your credit score, it is probably because you want to qualify for new lines of credit, such as a mortgage or car loan, in the future.
It is crucial to remember that credit score isn’t the only number that lenders consider. Your debt-to-income ratio, or DTI, is just as important as your credit score.
When lenders make a credit decision, they look at the monthly debts of a consumer and compare them to the monthly income of the consumer. If you have monthly bills that eat up most of your paycheck, it will be hard to qualify for new lines of credit.
For this reason, student loan borrowers need to closely watch how their monthly payments get reported to the credit bureaus.
Sherpa Tip: Changing repayment plans can help your Debt-to-Income ratio.
If you are on the standard ten-year repayment plan for your federal loans, switching to a repayment plan with a lower monthly payment might make sense.
You can continue making larger payments to eliminate your debt as planned, but a lower monthly bill gets reported to the credit bureaus and improves your DTI.
Don’t Lose Sight of the Big Picture
If we focus too much on credit scores, it is easy to lose sight of more important goals. Just because something is good for your credit score doesn’t mean it is a good idea. Likewise, a decision might hurt your credit score, but it might also be the best choice.
There are two objectives that borrowers should always keep in mind:
- Borrowers Must Eventually Eliminate Their Student Loans – Sometimes people get caught up in the credit age component of their score, so they think it is a good idea to let their student loan linger. This is a mistake. Paying interest to temporarily inflate your credit score is usually a bad idea.
- The Goal of a High Credit Score is to Save Money on Interest – Nobody wants a high credit score for bragging rights. We want a high credit score so that we can qualify for future loans and get a favorable interest rate. Credit scores should be used to save money. Don’t spend money to improve your credit score.
What Student Loan Should I Pay Off First to Help My Credit Score
There isn’t one simple rule for determining the best loan to eliminate for credit score purposes.
Instead, borrowers should consider their current student loans and their future financial goals.
The following loans are all reasonable targets for credit improvements and other financial goals:
- The Largest Monthly Payment – Knocking out the student loan with the largest monthly payment will have the biggest impact on your debt-to-income ratio. If your goal is to buy a house, erasing the largest monthly payment may do the most good.
- The Smallest Loan Balance – If loan elimination is a major challenge and a distant goal, attacking the smallest loan will lead to the fastest result.
- The Newest Loan – Credit age is a factor in credit scores. If you pay off the newest loan first, it preserves older debts and improves your average credit age.
- Private Loans Before Federal – Private student loans are notoriously more difficult to repay than federal loans. Private lenders don’t offer income-driven repayment plans or student loan forgiveness. Because late payments and defaults are major risks to credit scores, eliminating the difficult student loans first can protect your credit score.
Sherpa Tip: Student loan refinancing is often a valuable shortcut for debt elimination.
Refinancing your loans may move your credit score up or down, but by locking in a low interest rate on a long-term loan, you can significantly improve your debt-to-income ratio.
The lenders offering the lowest rates on 20-year loans are listed here.
Student Loans and Credit Scores: Frequently Asked Questions
Over the years, I’ve received a ton of reader questions about credit scores.
The following questions are the ones I receive most often:
No. Student debt may increase or reduce your credit score, but credit agencies do not view student loans as unfavorable.
Absolutely. Student loans are not necessarily bad, and if you don’t miss payments, they can help your credit score considerably.
Generally speaking, if you are in the 500’s you will definitely need a cosigner, and it still might be a challenge. As you climb through the 600’s things, go from difficult to easy. (Lenders like LendKey and Splash are usually a good starting point for borrowers with credit score concerns.)
If your credit score is in the 700s, it is much easier to get approved and qualify for a low interest rate. Borrowers in this range that get denied normally have debt-to-income ratios to blame.